Al-Jazeerah: Cross-Cultural Understanding

Opinion Editorials, December 2018

Share the link of this article with your facebook friends


Al-Jazeerah History


Mission & Name  

Conflict Terminology  


Gaza Holocaust  

Gulf War  




News Photos  

Opinion Editorials

US Foreign Policy (Dr. El-Najjar's Articles)




President Trump's Presidency:

Results and Perspectives

By James Petras

Al-Jazeerah, CCUN, December 3, 2018 


President Trumpís Presidency: Results and Perspectives


We need an objective evaluation of the Presidentís foreign and domestic polices Ė
the means, the goals, their results and consequences. The Trump performance requires
we discuss the style and substance of foreign and domestic policies.

We will ignore the fly swatting by Trump critics who ply peripheral issues Ė the
state investigation of the fading Russian conspiracy tales--- and focus on strategic issues
that purport to transform global economic, political and social relations.

ĎTrump at Workí: Foreign Policy

President Trump has a strategy and he works hard at realizing it.
High on Trumpís agenda is, first and foremost, asserting US global supremacy by
word and deed.

In pursuit of world power, he utilizes multiple weapons: he believes in the magic
powers of weapons and words. He asserts that prior Presidents Ďwere weak and allowed
others to exploit usí. Today, under Trumpís leadership, he claims we are strong and
flexing our power everywhere at all time.

How does the President reveal strength? Through multiple wars, severe
sanctions, increased military spending and greater concentration of wealth, in strategic

As a result, according to Trump, we intimidate rivals, competitors and

Trump cites numerous examples. In Syria, we occupy regions, build new military
bases, hire and arm more mercenaries and drop larger bombs on more Syrian cities.
Trump boasts that he weakens Iran by ending the nuclear agreement, increasing sanctions
precipitating an imminent collapse and regime change. Trump trumpets the success of the
economic trade war against China and the downfall of Russia by encircling them with
nuclear missiles , military bases and economic sanctions.

Trump hails new political successes and military allies in Latin America.

Argentina,Brazil, Colombia, Chile and Ecuador are viewed as Trumpís market successes
and providing a vassal army to overthrow the governments of Venezuela, Cuba and

Trump brags about his success in Ďrenegotiatingí NAFTA, renaming it and
claiming more favorable trade Ďdealsí with Mexico and Canada.

The European Union and each of its members have felt the wrath of Trumpís
threat of trade wars, and his demands for greater military contributions to NATO.
He has demanded the Germans buy US oil and gas instead of Russian; he
threatens to sanction European corporations who dare to abide by agreements with Iran;
Trump boasts of hundred-billion-dollar arms sale with Saudi Arabia, while affirming US
supremacy in the Middle East and North Africa.

President Trump, according to his bluster and boisterous self-acclaim, has won
every war, conquered all competitors and has laid the groundwork for an ĎAmerican

How many of Trumpís foreign policy twitters correspond to the real world and
how many are empty-handed ejaculations?

President Trump: Claims and Reality

Trumpís foreign policy strategy is mostly bluster than conquest, more boisterous
than business, more bluff than success.

Letís start with Russia. Trumpís sanctions and military encirclement have failed
to weaken Russia. Berlin deepens trade ties with the Kremlin Ė buys more oil and gas,
builds pipelines and affirms EU autonomy in dealing with Russia. Military encirclement
involves third rate Baltic partners, and missile bases stationed in Poland. In contrast
Russia has deepened multi-billion-dollar military and economic agreements with China, a
world power.

Russia has responded to Trumpís ending of nuclear missile agreements by
building superior weaponry. By any measure, Russia has defeated Trumpís sanctions and
military threats.

Despite Trumpís bombast about Ďsqueezing Chinaí with tariffs, Chinaís trade
surplus with the US has increased, while the US trade deficit has risen.

The US has grown by 2.8%, Chinaís by 6.5%. The US has failed to convince any
of its Asian allies to join its trade war against China. On the contrary, US so-called trade
war has encouraged Asia to replace US exporters. While Trumpís economic advisers
threaten Wall Streetís largest bankers to stop making billion dollar deals with China,
most have brushed Trump off. The bankers ignore Trumpís Ďtrade warí because profits
count more than gaseous rhetoric.

Saudi Arabia signs a $110 billion-dollar military agreement with Trump and then
buys only 10% . . . Ďfake dealsí to paraphrase the President.

Trumpís claim that the Saudis are a great ally ,yet it boycotts Qatar, which houses
the biggest US military base in the region. Israel, Trumpís Middle East ally, ignores
Trumpís economic sanctions with Russia and trade war with China, two of its biggest
high-tech trade partners.

The US wars are losing propositions. Afghan rebels control most of the country,
surround the provincial capitals and force US generals to seek withdrawal. US allies in
Syria have retreated. He relies on Kurdish separatists who have their own agenda, not

In Latin America, Trump collects kudos from far-right regimes in Brazil and
Argentina which hover on the verge of economic collapse, social crisis and political

Domestic Success of Dubious Value

Trump trumpets his big tax cut for billionaires with overseas holdings. He claims
it is a success story Ė creating jobs and producing growth. In fact, over three quarters of
the returned profits have resulted in buy-backs increasing corporate dividends not
investment in productive activity.

Trumpís trade war with China has not added jobs Ė it has added cost for
consumers through higher prices.

His pro-business policies have strengthened the leverage of corporations in
securing multi-billion-dollar concessions from local and state governments. Jeff Bezos
the multi-billion dollar owner of Amazon, received over $10 billion dollars in tax
exemptions, in addition to state financed concessions.

In effect Trumpís large scale, long-term income transfers benefit the rich over the
poor, increase inequalities and lowering public funds for education, health and welfare.
Trumpís opposition to public health for all, international climate change
agreements, national infrastructure investments and regulation of bank oversight, has
increased the risk of natural disasters , financial crises and transport breakdowns.
Despite his retrograde domestic program, Trump retains electoral support and
does not face an immediate political threat ---for one basic reason: The Democrats offer
no alternatives.

The corporate Democrats who lead the Party, back all of his retrograde policies:
they support Trumpís increases in military spending; support tax reduction for the rich;
oppose a national health program for all.

Moreover, during Democratic President Obamaís two terms in office, trillions of
dollars bailed out the biggest banks while 3 million households suffered foreclosures;
minimum wages remained below the poverty level; inequalities widened ,as did racial

Under President Obama 2 million immigrants were seized and expelled,
establishing a precedent for Trumpís anti-asylum policies.

In other words, Trumpís policies are a continuation and exacerbation of the
Obama regime.


Trumpís domestic and foreign policy demagogically capitalized on the failures of
the Democratic Partyís corporate socio-economic programs and multiple wars.

As a result, Trumpís exploited popular discontent and attracted big business
support by promising lower taxes and the end of regulations. In practice Trumpís
aggressive foreign and domestic policies contributed and added to Washingtonís isolation
and decline. None of Trumpís original objectives have been achieved. The US has
multiplied adversaries who have grown stronger and more unified. Washington has lost
established markets without gaining new ones. His original electoral support has
declined without gaining new adherents. Trumpís reliable Ďalliesí (Israel, Saudi Arabia
Germany, etc.) have undermined his aggressive trade policies to China and Russia. Anti
Iran sanctions have exempted the biggest buyers of Teheranís oil exports. If Trump has
failed to secure his domestic and foreign policy objectives these failures have not led to
any major loss of influence.

Europe is internally divided and unable to formulate any consequential
alternatives. Latin America faces economic crises which precludes any joint military
intervention despite Ďpaper agreementsí.

But the biggest failure is Trumpís policies to China. Each and everyone of
Trumpís major Asian allies has retained and increased trade agreements with Beijing.
Trumpís premature celebration of diplomatic victory over North Korea has evaporated.
North Korea has returned to and extended ties with China and Russia.

Trumpís strategic decisions have failed to secure his objectives. Not a single
world-shaking change has taken place. Trumpís generals may abandon Afghanistan but
no thanks to the Democrats or Europeans.

Trump trade wars with China has failed to secure more jobs in America, but his
Wall Street critics have negotiated bigger and more lucrative financial deals.

In a word, Trumpís failures have not led to greater and better conditions for
global markets, nor ended wars or improved living standards. Nevertheless many
progressives are pleased by Trumpís failures even though they are not beneficiaries.


Share the link of this article with your facebook friends




Opinions expressed in various sections are the sole responsibility of their authors and they may not represent Al-Jazeerah & &